. But by playing i run into several bug glitches and I also get some suggestions. I know that there is some pinned post about that but a lots of things in diffrent section are connected and it will be a real mess if i post that in 3 or 4 topics.This is going to be a long post (heh its like a complete review ... nan ...kiding) (This is more a post for the attention of the mod author)
-In general: -I know its a long thing to do but get a image/icon for all "wip" would be great.
-Putting more music ... playing for like 4 hours and only two musics are playing.
-Walls and buildings should be made a lot more toughter then they are. (Having your main gate breached by unarmed
peasants in less then 1 min. ARG !)
-Some factions have a missing "select all heros button" but I'm still able to select all the heros it just don't appear.
-Heros: In overall you did nice job by bringing new heros in the game but i do tink some are in needs of improvements or new heros
-Gondor: -Damrod: ok
-Boromir: -> perhaps add an invulnerability power or a battle rage
-Faramir: ok
-Imrahil: adding a power like glorious charge
-Aragorn: ok
-Gandalf: ok
-New hero: the weird guy who is with faramir in osgiliath attack i tink its is lieutnant but i don't remember is name
-New hero: Denethor ? but really here i'm not sure about it.
-Elves: -Sam: ok
-Arwen: ok
-Haldir: ok
-Glorfindel: ok
-Legolas: ok
-Thranduil: ok
-Elrond: ok
-Galadriel: when she died a "shockwave" come out but do nothing and it said like "elrond is dead"
-Celeborn: When he died the death of elrond sound is playing
-Elrohir: same as celeborn
-Elladan: same as celeborn
-Dwarves: -Bilbo: He really need one more power like he use the ring to disappear or a mithril armor power or maybe something
about the Arkenstone.
-Prince Bard: ok
-Gloin: ok
-King Brand: A "king's blessing" power or a "Black Arrow" power (instantly kill a monster, level 10 power) would be
great
-Thorin III: ok
-Borin IV: ok
-King Dain: ok
-Gimli: ok
-Isengard: -Wulf: fix the levels for the powers i have lvl 3 power at level 1
-Ugluk: he don't have any powers ?
-Lurtz: ok
-Sharku: ok
-Wormtongue: ok
-Saruman: ok
-Mordor: -Snaga: one more power like battle rage
-Gothmog: ok
-Akhurahil: ok
-Dendra Dwar: ok
-Hoarmurath: ok
-Morgomir: ok
-Ren the Unclean: ok
-Uvatha: ok
-Mouth of Sauron: ok
-Burzolog: ok
-Witch King: ok
-New hero: the orc with a missing nose in the return of the king extended edition (the one who inspect the orc legion
in wich there is sam and frodo) or perhaps as a new unit: "Orc Inspector"
-Goblins: -Goblin King: ok
-Azog: ok
-Shelob: one more power like one when she can throw spider web to nearby enemy units who can't move anymore and
die after some time
-Duramlug: ok
-Ghundur: ok
-Lozennarja: ok
-Drogoth: ok
-New hero: as "ring hero" I propose Smaug
-Angmar: Coming soon.
-Arnor: -Argeleb: one more power like summuning battalions of Fornost Guard
-Carthaen: ok
-Arvedui: ok
-Arveleg: ok
-Cirdan: ok
-Elrond: ok
-Rohan: -Meriadoc: ok
-Gamling: ok
-Hama: hero assistance power is not working
-Eowyn: ok
-Eomer: ok
-Erkenbrand: ok
-Theoden: ok
-Radgast: ok
-New hero: Theodred
-MotE: -Mahud Chieftain: No powers ? I would give him powers like Assasin, Horn of the Haradrims, Mounting an Oliphant, etc.
-Easterling Captain: ok
-Ji Indur: ok
-Khamul: ok
-Morinehtar: no powers ?
-Romestamo: no powers ?
-New hero: Its a powerful female warrior an haradrim I found somewhere reading tolkien books but its been so long i
can't remember her name.
-Maps tagged "RJ": Here I'm talking only about the castles because I havn't played much on these maps but I've that you bring new things on the map, perhaps too much in density I mean.
-Gondor: Its good but perhaps extend it a little bit to provide more space.
-Elves: Ok but the walls really need to be improved (blending, war towers).
-Dwarves: Good but same as Gondor for space.
-Isengard: Good
-Mordor: Good
-Goblins: Good
-Angmar: Wow nicely done
-Arnor: same as Gondor
-Rohan: Missing wall corner (but I only tested then on Cair Andros map)
-MotE: Perhaps larger walls to allowed men on top of them + corsair ballista wall improvement
And perhaps give an other fortress disposition for Harad.
-Units, Building, etc bugs and suggestions on regular maps: One word: WOW ! I really like the way you put a music for each faction at the loading screen and the different views very cool.
-Gondor: Well not much to say about this faction.
-When the Citadel Guards are upgraded with fire arrows the fire texture don't appear and they still shot normal arrows.
-Pikemens, Knights, Soldiers, Archers heavy armor skin missing
-The faction really need another foot unit like peasants or perhaps Itilien Guards
-Elves: Also not much to say about them.
-Fix the flashing mist around the "Shrine to Iluvatar" its really getting on my nerves (I destroyed the shrine for that !) and
perhaps adding a visible war tower at level 3 upgrade.
-Lorien archers and Lorien warrior heavy armor skin missing
-Lorien warrior, Mithlond Sentry, Rivendell Lancers forged blades missing skin
-Perhaps increase alittle bit the Ent resistance to fire.
-Give War Towers to elven walls woulb be great.
-I noticed that the views buttons are missing when playing with elves.
-Give the elven fortress a horn upgrade (elven horn) ->power associated: calling for reinforcements: four elven battalions
come out of the fortress.
-Add Galadhrims warriors or replace Lorien warriors by them.
-Dwarves: ...
-Siege hammer guardian missing (only spawn regular guardians)
-Isengard: Well not much things have changed there.
-Wildmens of Dunland heavy armor skin missing.
-Give the fortress the horn upgrade (Isengard horn) ->power associated: I havn't tink about it yet.
-Mordor: I liked the way you made them an orc faction.
-Forged blades skin missing
-The doors on the walls have the wrong animation, I tink you you use the one from Dol Guldur (BFME 2).
-Orc trackers fire arrows skin missing and they fire normal arrows.
-After purchase fellbeasts upgrade at the fortress, nothing happen. Where to train them how to equid the nazguls with
them ?
-Perhaps add to mordor fortress the horn upgrade (the one playing when the Black Door open in The two Towers) -> power
associated: cancel cloud break power and 50 % armor bonus to all orcs.
-Goblins: ...
-Goblin pikemen forged blades skin missing
-Give the fortress the Drums upgrade -> power associated: spawn sevral goblin units anywhere in the radius of the
fortress.
-Angmar: A few things to say.
-Snow troll heavy armor skin missing
-Easterling captain have no power and can't level up, he stay at level 0
-Make the summoned units (Rhudaur Pikemen and Rhudaur Axe Thrower) upgradable with banner carrier, forged blades
and heavy armor.
-Add a cavalry unit recruitable from lvl 2 Hall named Black Numenorean Riders upgradable with banners, forged blades and
heavy armor.
-Arnor: Heh you did a really good job by bringing new buildings and the "alliances" system, I really liked that but it still need some
improvements.
-I propose to add cavalry stables to the faction wich can be named King's Stables with a building animation and a building
who looks in the same way as the barracks or the armory.
-Add a cavalry unit wich will be a basic cavalry unit upgradable with banners, forged blades, heavy armor. I propose
the name Arnor Lancers. Recruitable from lvl 1 cavalry stables.
-Add another cavalry unit upgradable with shields, banners, forged blades, heavy armor. I propose the name King's
Bodyguards. Recruitable from lvl 2 stables.
-Move Royal Guard units from barracks to stables (lvl 3).
-Add catapult and/or postern gate to Arnor walls.
-Add a pikemen unit to the barracks upgradable with banners, forged blades, heavy armor. Name: Cardolan Pikemen
(barracks lvl 2).
-Add a heavy pikemen unit to barracks upgradable with banners, forged blades, heavy armor with a special ability: Glorious
Stand wich give them a huge damage and defense bonus. Name: Fornost Guard. Only two units allowed at same time.
-Change the building of the Siege work for a one who looks the same way as other (currently using Gondor building).
-Give the fortress a wall upgrade.
-Give the fortress a "super-power" like the others. I propose Earth Hammer.
-Heavy armor skins missing.
-Give an animation to barracks, elven barracks, ranger tent and armory buildings.
-Perhaps upgradable Hobbits.
-Give them a market building ? -> alliance with traders.
-Adding a "Shrine to the Seven Stars" building but I'm not sure here.
-Rohan: Also thre a nice job have been done.
-Give Yeoman Herald a spawning sound.
-Change the sound when the herald summoned a unit (actually playing angmar sound).
-Perhaps give the barracks an animation (like two guards at the entrance).
-The morning mist animation on walls is missing.
-Perhaps change the horn of the fortress to Helm's Deep horn.
-Change the foot units shields for round shields.
-Perhaps too much foot units selection.
-MotE: Wow i really liked played as them and its probably the most complete faction.
-Harad: -Animations needed for harad farm, stables and armory.
-Change the bazaar building for a new one (actually usiing Gondor building).
-Mumakils can't level up ?
-Dude ! Size down the size of the Oliphant...Awwwwww. And decrease alittle bit their vulnerability to fire.
-Add a visible tower to lvl 3 stables who fire arrows.
-Fortress: -Give the poison arrows upgrade an animation (like cups around with green liquid).
-Give the oasis upgrade an animation (like a little lake with palm trees around it or a little river snaking
between the fortress buildings with palm trees).
-Change the scorpion den building for a new one.
-Give the fortress at least a siege upgrade. I mean like you can build on plots, here you build towers or
scorpion den, a sized down corsair ballista (but same range).
-Change the horn for a new one like the one who play when the oliphants charge in the pelennor field
battle.
-Don't give them walls but perhaps a barricade not in wood but will looks like the top of mumakil pen (the roof).
-Add battering ram ? but I'm not sure about it.
-Rhun: -Fortress: -Make the sanctuary upgrade visible.
-Buildable wall hub from fortress plots
-Give a "super-power" upgrade (Havn't tink about it yet).
-Visible banners ?
-Give animation to stables and armory buildings.
-Level up visible upgrade for stables (tower firing arrows, for barracks too).
-Istari alcove visible level up upgrade.
-Add a siege work building recruiting battering ram and siege beast (a sized up beast who looks like the one who are
on the dwarven demolisher.
-Soldier of Rhun forged blades and heavy armor skin missing.
-Easterlings archers fire arrows skin missing they still fire normal arrow.
-Easterling warriors heavy armor skin missing.
-A completly new spell book. (as soon as I have ideas I'll write them down)
-Good Campaign: Wow the mine of moria were really well done I enjoyed slauthering goblins but at the beginning I was like "Awww
crap I'm so dead" like in the movie. I did have the time however to bring Gandalf to level 5 so hehe...
What I played there really make my want to do the Helm's Deep battle or Minas Tirith (this should be fun ... DIE, DIE, DIE *darkside points* ugly orcs), orthe battle at the Back Gate (you will fill the waves with orcs I hope ... hmm GAndalf word of power will be devastating hehehe).
-Evil Campaign: Well pretty much the same but I guess there is still lots of work with this one because Isengard was very buggy.
NOTE: My english is very bad so please forgive me for that.
If you need screenshots to understand some things don't hesitate to ask me.
Scythiak
