But like ithronaiwendil sayed in the other topic Carcharot and Draugluin lived and died in the 1st age then Gil Galad are plausible, and he received on of the three rings like Galadriel and Círdan, and he was the last High King of the Noldor.
He actually received 2 of the rings. You seem to be missing the point I'm trying to make. Those other heroes you mention are all part of a hero-light faction. Elves are not hero-light (infact probably tied with Men as most hero-heavy).
And zimoo Legolas can't be out otherwise will be a non sense to have gimli cuz he didn't do nothing too.
I'd rather Legolas get kicked out than Galadriel, Celeborn, Thranduil or Elrond. Gimli did do stuff though, he helped shore up the defences at Helms Deep thus giving the defenders more time.
Elrond can't be out cuz he fought in the last alliance battle, he is the leader of Rivendell(remenbering that Rivendell is on of the most important citys of the elves in the Middle Earth), Elrond is the brother of Elros the King of numenoreans, he is extremely important in the War of the north and he is in the White Council.
So because he fought in the last alliance he should be added? In that case we need Cirdan as a hero too.
To say Rivendell is one of the most important elven cities means nothing really. They've got what...4 cities?
Galadriel was the one who organised the white council, yet you proposed to kick her out. And also, if you're going to say Elrond was 'extremely important in the War of the North', could I see some quotes to support that?