1149 replies to this topic

[CIL]

Ava- 7/10: Rather pointless, but entertaining to look at.

Siggy- 10/10: Good quote, good userbar and a fantastic custom bar... thingy. Gets a good rap in my book.

[Vithar-133]

7/10 av. hard to tel whether it's a violin, viola, cello or what from the size.

6/10 sig. I like the userbars, but the colours don't match up well. The politcal compass takes it down as well.

[CIL]

Firstly, that little yellow thing under where the chinrest goes gives it away that it's a violin, as does the fine tuner. There's also the fact that it looks old, and as there are very few 3/4 old violins, it's easy to tell.

Avatar- 3/10: Don't like the clones or Sidious, but Star Wars is okay. I liked the old one more.

Siggy- 6/10: I like the violinist, fencer and Footsteps of Doom userbar, but I dislike the others... and that thing in the middle is just a bit odd. I do like the quote.

Edited by CIL, 04 April 2009 - 08:52 PM.

[Puppeteer]

6/10 = Yay for stringed instruments, nay for ambiguity.
4/10 = It's very disorganised, the sig bars have different text alignments and the colours contrast badly... oh and an awfully fixed compass.

Edited by Puppeteer, 03 April 2009 - 07:59 PM.

[Vithar-133]

9/10 both. A nice blue/white colour scheme. Very calming.

[Vortigern]

I would first like to say that I agree with Vithar about Puppeteer's avatar and signature. They do provide a thoroughly relaxing moment when encountered. Well done.

Avatar: 4/10. I don't like Star Wars at all, as I'm sure you know, but it seems like a decent picture. Objectivity raises your score a little.
Signature: 8/10. I actually like the setup you have here with the userbars, and it's a good quote. I haven't got around to reading your story yet, but I had a brief look at your website. Just so you know.

[Caspa]

Avatar 4/10 - What the fuck is it?
Signature 8/10 - Still nicely organised and easy on the eye.

Also, LFG still rocks. For Pony!

[Copaman]

7/10: A classic, with a Revora twist!

10/10: FUCKING HILARIOUS!

[Bart]

8: very artsy
7: nice picture, true message, but unnecessarily big

[Neth]

9/10 - Avatar - What can I say? Its Minas Tirith
6/10 - Sig - Quite plain but very neat

[Caspa]

Avatar 7/10 - Looks rather childishly done. I like it.
Signature 5/10 - It's green, bulky and uninspiring. Sorry
Coloured Text 5/5 - To the point and honest.

[Bart]

ava 6: kind of aggresive
sig 6: amusing. actually made me look up katy perry. however, misspelled her name
colored text (the new trend): 8: very KISS (keep it simple stupid)

[True Lord of Chaos]

Colored text? Do you mean like the blue, red, and green text? And since when do you crawl into the junkyard?
@Caspa: The green text says it's yellow. It's green. Trust me.

9/10 I like how it looks like it's made of ice.
8/10 Not too much, but userbars are nice

[The Best Guest]

5/10 not much of a slipknot fan

8/10 puppeteer fan brings up any sig

[Vithar-133]

7/10 av. Not sure what it's supposed to be...but it looks cool.
6/10 sig. Lots of stuff. and not center aligned. It bugs me. But the LotR stuff helps it out. Alittle.

[Bart]

av 7: i needed to look 3 seconds to recognize it, but yeah, clone troopers are
sig 6: too busy

[Vithar-133]

7/10 av. Like LotR.
8/10 sig. simple. But not center aligned.

[The Best Guest]

(its a dwarf from the game war of the ring)
8/10 for av .go starwars

7/10 for sig. gotta love RPGs

[Bart]

av 6: hard to recognize, while an avatar is your online face
sig 6: too big and doesn't have links (other than {IP})

[segwayrulz]

av: 8/10 nice i like glaciers
sig: 5/10 one of the pics is a red X so its either my internet stuffing up or a broken link.