1712 replies to this topic

[robnkarla]

Add any suggestions and/or bugs for Arnor in here. I want to seperate the factions for discussion.

ToDo:
- Big item - Redo and make Arnor more unique in terms of structures, walls, upgrades, etc.
- Redo the elves with unique models.

Bugs:
- Ensure that the Arnor bases uses the Arnor fortress instead of the Men

Edited by robnkarla, 07 July 2007 - 09:07 PM.

[Devon]

can men and elves make combo hordes? may not be realistic, but would be cool

[robnkarla]

can men and elves make combo hordes? may not be realistic, but would be cool

That is one of the things that I really like about Arnor. I'm going to allow them to combine.

So far the units that I have planned (not yet done):
1) Soldiers, Archers, and elven pikemen
2) Towerguards, rangers
3) Knights, rivendell-archers
4) Imladriswarriors

I'm going to be going through these units and changing it up though. I'd like to have at least 1 more elven unit, and take out the gondor clones.

We'll see how they turn out. Arnor has always been the last one I work on, tbh.

[Dalf32]

Arveleg and Arvedui hav the same skin, and i dont think Arnor Elven Wood shuld b castable inside bases in bfme1/2 revisited maps. i also noticed that u cant capture castles once they are destroyed, so u cant rebuild on them and expand, not entirely sure wether or not this was intentional.

[Nothingness]

Just a few things i noticed. The upgrade for the istari isn't in the fortress upgrades. When you buy builders they have the gondor buildings rather then arnors. Defense plots dont always show up but you can still bring up the selection by clicking where they should be.

[Zyzzyva]

While I dont really know, since I was playing against arnor rather than as arnor, it seems to me that the regular Arnor Soldiers are quite OP. One troop could take down a goblin resource building in a remarkably short time, short enough that with Gorkil, Azog, and numerous goblin hordes I still couldn't stop them from tearing down my buildings that were not protected by my fortress faster than I could build them . Anyways, thats what it seems to me. Of course, I havent played Arnor so I dont really know.

[Ergopad]

That is one of the things that I really like about Arnor. I'm going to allow them to combine.

So far the units that I have planned (not yet done):
1) Soldiers, Archers, and elven pikemen
2) Towerguards, rangers
3) Knights, rivendell-archers
4) Imladriswarriors

I'm going to be going through these units and changing it up though. I'd like to have at least 1 more elven unit, and take out the gondor clones.

We'll see how they turn out. Arnor has always been the last one I work on, tbh.

I was just thinking that, if Gondor units have new textures (as I've understood), Arnor units (from motw) would use yellow/orange (forged armor upgrade) textures?

What I don't like about, are the towerguards, since they so distinctly look like Gondorians. Maybe remove them completly and add some elven unit, rivendell lancers or Lindon Horse Archers as elite cavalry perhaps?

Are there going to be any elven heroes too with different powers (like WK)?

Have you already decided what will be Arnor's symbol, how about star?

Edited by Ergopad, 10 July 2007 - 03:04 AM.

[el kevo]

Well Arnor was fun to play with:

The archer/sword elves you get at the elven barracks sometimes jump off the walls and end up on the ground

When you build a trebuchet expansion no trebuchet appears and when you click on it to build one it won't let you build one because it thinks theres one there

[Dalf32]

arnor banner upgrade frum the fortress dosnt lower the price of the bilders, and arnor needs its own original upgrades at the fortress. the fire arrows r still greyed out until u get numenor stonework, not sure if thats intentional; and the istari power thing at the fortress has no visible change wen u buy it.

arnor towers/trebuchets at the fortress dont upgrade with numenor stonework, they remain the old texture.
arnor and angmar inns r not the new variety (with the different subfaction upgrades).

thats all 4 now. note: this is still 1.05.00, i havnt gotten 1.05.01 yet, downloading that 2nite.

edit: carthaen dosnt attack wen u switch him 2 wielding his sword.

Edited by Dalf32, 17 July 2007 - 05:24 PM.

[el kevo]

Cartheran and Glorfindel both have the WK heal bug (they won't heal fast but very slowly)

[dojob]

Arnor farms still have radii.



I'm not sure if other factions' resource buildings have them or whether this has already been noticed, but I think that the radii should be completely removed now that expansion is very limited.

[mr_g]

on 1.05.02
in the Istari power there is 2 Saruman, I don't remember if there is 2 on previous version

[Lord_Denethor]

What you mean is when you use The Istari Power. There is Two Sarumans, Two Gandalfs, and then just Radagast. The Models havent been switched for Alatar and Pollando. So that could require fixing. Oh and i dont know if it was my computers graphics or the mod but when Arveleg uses his Smash Palantir Power the Graphics get screwed up, The Palantir is just a blue art box. Also another bug is that Elves cant recieve the banner upgrades.

[mr_g]

Oops, bad explications! lol
I just want to say there are two who are named Saruman

[Lord_Denethor]

Dunedain Soliders require fx for upgraded swords, and upgraded armor, and if possible could you use the Dunedain Solider skin for the Dunedain Knights? Because right now they are just Gondor Knights, and lol i like uniqueness, and difference between faction. Its not your fault, EA was the one who didnt change the stinken skins.

Edited by Lord_Denethor, 27 July 2007 - 05:37 PM.

[Vithar-133]

Just a couple of suggestions, seeing as arnor was around at the Last Alliance, maybe you could add Gil-Galad? just thought that would be intresting, also if you could place the dunedain rangers to Arnor's archery range, to replace Ithilien Rangers, that would make more sense as arnor would not have had ithilien rangers.

Edited by Sword_of_the_North, 28 July 2007 - 06:37 PM.

[mr_g]

Dunedain Rangers are named Ithilien Rangers in the Archery Range

[Vithar-133]

@mr g: Not quite, they aren't the same, at least not quite. No Weapon Switch.

[mr_g]

I know they are not the same, it's just on the archery they must be called dunedain rangers and not ithilien rangers
that's hard to be really good understand for a french, lol

[Jepa]

What I don´t like is that there are too many elven units in arnor and also gondor units. Arnor doesn`t have some uniq units or? Change the elven units to somthing other something remade or new unit, play with arnor is like play with elfs,kind of.