475 replies to this topic

[Rafv Nin IV]

The trample issue is a bug. Currently, when you run over half-trolls with Rohirrim (I'm not sure whether it's Rohirrim or all cav), they deal trample revenge damage but don't actually get trampled.

[Devon]

Rob fixed that one for the next version after I was whining to him when you beat me

[Neth]

So thats the bug you wouldn't tell me about when I was being Goblins and you were being Rohan

[Uruk King]

Still, I think that the Half-trolls should be replaced with Gundabad orcs, more resilient forms of orc bearing pikes and swords like the half-trolls, only they aren't as absurdly outside the lore, or OP.

[Rafv Nin IV]

Just change the names, then.

[Uruk King]

No, more than that, not half-troll like creatures but orcs of a similar size to Mordor orcs, but more powerfully built, like the current black orcs.

[Thorin IV]

Half-Trolls aren't OP they cost a fortune!

[shadowcreature]

Gundabad Orcs do sound like an interesting replacement for the Half-Trolls. I'm ok with that or some sort of Wild Uruk for replacement of them.

[{IRS}Athos]

Perhaps scaling down the Half-Trolls would be sufficient to make them more orclike. Their art is fine, in my opinion.

[Devon]

Bolg's Bodyguard.

[Lord Aragorn]

i agree that the half-trolls must be replaced;they are originally from Far Harad and you can put them to the haradrim faction;instead,it is a good idea about the orcs of gundabad;they aren't far away to be goblins,especially if they live in the misty mountains

[{IRS}Athos]

It seems to me like the goblin pikes are far too resilient for their appearance. They're wearing nothing but a loincloth and not even carrying shields like their sword counterparts, and yet they can take many more hits before kicking the bucket. Their armor may need adjustment...

[Ring o' Fate]

i agree that the half-trolls must be replaced;they are originally from Far Harad

Try again. The Books said that people LOOKED, key word LOOKED, like Half-Trolls.
And Ithilien, have you looked at their freaking cost? It's more than 2 archer hordes and a swordsman horde. Which don't carry shields EITHER!

Edited by Ring of Fate, 08 June 2009 - 06:13 AM.

[{IRS}Athos]

Ringy, my point was that their cost and armor should be adjusted according to their appearance. It doesn't make sense that a single pikeman wearing a loincloth could stand up to more than one hit by a hero.

Also, did you see those weird wooden things that the swordsmen are carrying? They're called shields.

Edited by ithilienranger732, 08 June 2009 - 06:35 PM.

[Ring o' Fate]

They don't carry shields, they...Oh, yeah, I play on Ultra low.

[Devon]