for scryer :
i still dont get it, i wrote that the spell would have SMALL radius, not too small of course, but it could poison at least 2 batalions. soo you just keep saying your own stuff at this point ( no offense now ). Next, you said that you would send them on suicide, thats true, thats the point,, to weaken enemy, and make him do what you want. Now for karash, you really think its op ? REALLY ? try play him, not just watch him, until lvl 5 that aura is uselles, cant even kill hobits, AFTER lvl 5 it gets interesting though, but still its radius is just soo big that only the closest enemies get hit by it, the range is smaller than attack range of karsh himself, which makes you send him to enemies instead of letting him normal attack. And for more, i was speaking about karsh, only for you to be able to create image of how the spell would look.
next you r saing that the invulnearibilty spell ( sorry for shit spelling ) is like glorious charge, OF COURSE IT IS LIKE, but its not the same glorious make units take 10% of dmg, soo they can be still killed, and its duration is loong enough to tear down half of enemy base. This power ( mine ) is 20 sec. or less invuln. for your units near the hero, it was based on GCH, but the hero himself wont get invuln. only units, ( theoden goes glorious too, when casting that thing of ojs ). The main point of this hero is late game support, he is like edge that allows you to strike deep in enemy formations, thats why i suggested him, his price and his power soo that he is Late game hero, like Witchking or Drogoth.
you said Haradrim would newer serve under him. This might be true, but look at this this way, THEY ARE in alliance, thx to Sauron. Soo there is some contact. THEY ARE the only EVIL MAN race, soo they have closer to each thant to some weird ugly mutated orks. And finally, i think both races have some kind of objectives that a leader should have, Soo i think if ( according to the whole stuff i already said, before and now ) if that Hero would have all this abilities ( now i dont mean abilities like spell, but like personal skills ), then i dont see why they shouldnt follow him. Look in history, there are many famous leaders and comanders, for example Napoloen, later he had mixed army of many nations and they followed him. this is just example.
The point is there can alway rise a hero that will shape many nations togather and lead them to their destiny
( lol this sounds like from some fantasy teaser
)
more than this, you wrote they got ringwraiths, wizards ilusions etc etc. To the ilusions, first of all the wizard summons ilusions, and second, they are only good for Multiplayer game, as decoy unit. Pc with its scriptet UI will just take rid of em and continue to next target. Honestly i think most people here, just want this mode for the Campaing, and WOTR game style, being happy with new races, and stuff. I dont believe that more than 20% of people will play this through online matches. We dont even know if this mod will be supporting multiplayer, and if it will be stable.... I myself wont play it through net and i dont believe im the only one who wont do it . . .
and after all this, i dont think that this is or will be " pointless clash of opinions" to tell the truth, im happy that i can speak with you like this, becouse from all this i can see you put your heart in your opinions, as i do too. Soo i take this positively ( spelling :( ). As i say, every other opinion, other than yours helps to enlarge you own sights.
just one word for uruk king : i think your Sandstorm power, isnt worth the points, unless it would deal some fair amount of dmg to enemy units sturtures. Every race has some kind of dmg power ( maybe goblins not, but dragon and balrog are more then enough for some serious dmg
)
And please, more to the Blades of rhun ability, you just typed " All infantry haradrim or eastelings " all what ? what thing it gives them ?? wtf ???
